Reading Jonathan Lopez's book about the master forger Han van Meegeren, The Man who made Vermeers, I was reminded of the opening sequence of the 70s T.V. series Tinker Tailor, Soldier, Spy; this featured a doll that contained other versions of itself with slightly different expressions, until we get to the last one which has a blank face. Van Meegeren seems to have been like that. I bet that you could never pin down the real McCoy; he seems to have been skilful at manufacturing different versions of himself just as much as imitations of his favourite, Jan Vermeer. "Made" in this sense was not solely about faking paintings, but also creating bogus identities, mythologizing one's achievements, leaving a trail of false clues. So many roles: embittered forger producing fake Vermeers to spite the critics; millionaire decadent organizing parties for prostitutes in Amsterdam; Dutch folk hero playing to his fans at his trail in 1947, while surrounded by his own art; Nazi sympathizer writing inscriptions to Adolf Hitler in books embellished by fascist hieroglyphs.
It's the focus on the Nazi dimension that makes Lopez's book so distinctive and compelling. He's really sharp- and persuasive- on van Meegeren's association with the Nazi aesthetic. In a probing analysis, the author shows how the forger's most infamous work, the Supper at Emmaus, an expressionist re-imagining of early Vermeer with spectral forms with ghoulish faces, approaches the Volkgeist, or the spirit of the people tied to Germanic customs. A comparison between a later painting, Mealtime at the Farm of 1942- a kind of Louis Le Nain peasant meal meets the spirit of Mein Kampf- and the Supper at Emmaus, makes that Nazi connection very convincing.
In his time van Meegeren fooled not only leading players like Hermann Goering who owned one of his Vermeer forgeries, The Woman taken in Adultery, but also eminent art historians. None were more elevated and acclaimed than Abraham Bredius, one of the architects of Rembrandt scholarship- his paintings have Bredius numbers- and a man responsible for helping to purchase an uncontested Vermeer, the Allegory of Faith. Bredius has suffered the eternal humiliation of declaring the Supper at Emmaus a true Vermeer; he wrote an article in the bible of connoisseurship, The Burlington Magazine, in 1937, proclaiming its autograph status. As Lopez says, history and art history has been very rough on Bredius because he was conned by a clever psychologist who knew how to exploit the great Dutch art historian's weakness. Van Meegeren knew that Bredius expected religious pictures to emerge from Vermeer's early career, the one period of his career where pictures were scarce. And there was a lot riding on that "Vermeer"; not only an end-of-career coup for Bredius, but the making of the Boymans Museum in Rotterdam and its new Director Dirk Hannema, who eventually bought the painting on Bredius's advice for what would be the equivalent of $4 million today. When everything unraveled, Bredius saw his world crumble to dust around him; I suspect that his major gaffe was partly why the Rembrandt Research project was set up, because some of his attributions must have been doubted in the light of his mistake in 1937. To be fair to Bredius though, he was responsible in the 1930s for cutting Rembrandt's hyper inflated oeuvre, a sad irony.
There's something about art history set against World War II that makes books like this read like thrillers at times. This is a world not only of curators and dealers but murderers, thieves and the military police. There are hairbreath scrapes like the time van Meegeren arouses Goering's suspicions about the provenance of the Adulteress. Who doesn't feel the same chill as van Meegeren when he is ordered by the Reichsmarschall to write a letter detailing the picture's history of ownership? How does one invent a provenance of a picture one has forged recently? Characteristically, van Meegeren hits on a brilliant solution: he writes Goering a letter saying that he will reveal the name of the owner within two year's time from the date of purchase. This is a masterstroke because it will confirm Goering's suspicions about the criminal origins of the Adulteress, while giving him an out with the letter; but it will draw attention away from the picture as a fake. This is a typical van Meegeren ploy betraying his attitude to life- an inveterate optimist sure of his ability to escape from the worst of all possible predicaments by guile and sense of the moment opportunism.
The forger's luck ran out when the Allies apprehended Goering's picture dealer Alois Miedl, whose confession allowed the Adulteress to be traced back to van Meegeren. Miedl, quite a character himself, lived out the rest of life in sunny Spain bolstered by the proceeds accumulated through his dodgy wartime dealing. Others who had done the same were not so fortunate. Hannema was punished for collaborating with the Nazis and for sending art directly to them from Holland, his part was a revelation to me. Soon everybody was running for cover, collaborators, morally bankrupt dealers, women who had literally slept with the enemy, against a Holland of vengeful cruelty gradually ceding to leniency, a mood brilliantly evoked by Lopez with his sympathetic summary of the situation and use of harrowing photos of traitors suffering at the hands of the wrathful Dutch. This is one of the best descriptions of the war time Dutch art scene since parts of Lynne Nicholas's indispensable The Rape of Europa.
I've read a few books on van Meegeren, mainly for a current course I'm teaching on art crime, but I still can't really fathom how he succeeded beyond the dreams of most forgers. His Supper at Emmaus looks nothing like a Vermeer, but the forger managed to fool Bredius into believing it was. You'll find some possible reasons by another van Meegeren scholar, Errol Morris here, and lots more besides, including more from Jonathan Lopez. There's also a humorous and insightful film by the Boyman's Museum here.
Van Meegeren's fabrications now inhabit a curious world of tainted celebrity. Pictures like the Lacemaker, one of his earliest forgeries from 1926, are immensely appealing; and in such pictures perhaps we can detect an honest desire to emulate Vermeer to the best of the forger's abilities. It is a tragedy that van Meegeren could only discover his artistic ability through forgeries- his paintings under his own name hardly quicken the pulse. Lopez pulls no punches here, but he is impartial and objective. Yet, at the end of his book, we seem to encounter the blank face of the final TTSS doll, not somebody with a face or real identity. Van Meegeren's most successful forgery was the portrait of himself he presented to the world.
Great post and review! I really enjoyed reading this book last year. I continually find reasons to refer back to this book - in fact, I looked up something in it yesterday afternoon!
I agree with what you said about Van Meegeren's artistic ability. He obviously was a very talented man, but spent his talent and ability trying to imitate Vermeer instead of working on his own abilities/strengths/creativity. It's a shame, because he really was talented (although, I do think that his "Supper at Emmaus" is quite ugly).
I've heard of "The Rape of Europa" book before - you've reminded me that I need to read it as well.
I'd love to sit in on your art crime course!
Posted by: M | 11/25/2010 at 07:49 PM
Yes, the book is really good.
I was reading your review of the FBI book the other day. I think I'll need to read that as next term we're looking at the fightback against art crime. So I need to find out more about the work of various polices forces and crime-fighting orgs.
I dipped into the "Rape of Europa" as I read Lopez. Their descriptions of the Dutch art scene during wartime are really fascinating.
Thanks again- David
Posted by: Art History Today | 11/25/2010 at 08:26 PM
There certainly is a lot of buzz about Priceless. I'll either have to put a hold on it at the library (already six ahead of me) or go buy a copy (forget Christmas shopping for others). I'll look for The Rape of Europa at the library - I see there are no holds on that one!
Another excellent book on art crime is The Caravaggio Conspiracy by Peter Watson. It's several years old now, but still available on Amazon. Watson, a journalist, also went undercover to try to find a stolen Caravaggio painting. The story is fascinating and the outcome more surprising than fiction.
Posted by: Val Span | 11/26/2010 at 06:09 PM
I'll order a copy of Priceless. I keep meaning to read the Caravaggio book, but haven't got around to it.
Posted by: Art History Today | 11/27/2010 at 03:24 PM
I'm always partial to anything about Vermeer. I must check out this book! I got my hands on a rare video documentary from 1997(pre DVD) about Vermeer the other day which I'm looking forward to watching.
Have you ever seen Peter Greenaway's "A Zed and Two Noughts" It was actually this film which introduced me to Vermeer and Van Meegeren.
H
Posted by: H Niyazi | 11/28/2010 at 04:15 PM
H
It is worth a read. I saw the Greenaway film on TV years ago. I don't think I was an art historian then, so never really picked up on the references.
Another Vermeer recommendation. Do you know Ivan Gaskell's 'Vermeer's Wager'? Very good ob V in relation to the museum and photography, and looking ahead to V in film in some ways.
Posted by: Art History Today | 11/28/2010 at 05:28 PM
Cheers for that David! I just discovered a great lecture on the NGA site featuring Mr Lopez talking about this very book
Here's the direct link :)
http://dl.luxmedia.com/nationalgallery/audio/012009lect02.mp3
H
Posted by: H Niyazi | 11/29/2010 at 09:02 AM
I just in addition to my own buddys had been located being studying the fantastic tips from the web page even though out of the blue became a terrible hunch I had developed not necessarily thanked your blog user for anyone techniques. These types of children ended up undoubtedly as being a very happy to go through the christmas presents and also have simply really been recently utilizing these tips. We appreciate you your current actually currently being very well helpful then regarding getting this kind of fantastic valuable instructions many people are actually planning to discover. Many of our trustworthy repent intended for not really stating because of anyone quicker.
http://www.robotsxml.org/wiki/index.php/Dental_Lasers_Are_Patient_Friendly_Advancements_In_Dentistry
http://www.dailystrength.org/people/1777275/journal/4182110
http://4wyboxq.jigsy.com/entries/general/getting-over-your-dentist-fear
http://webdirectoryworld.info/dentist-in-encino/
http://billiondollarwiki.watchfreeinternettvonline.com/index.php?title=Blue_Cross_Dental_Insurance_policy
Thanks a lot to the article. I enjoy the composing model – Im wanting to commence a blog site me personally, In my opinion I may learn through your entire articles and reviews for a lot of recommendations! Cheers as soon as.
Posted by: ilhfaee | 06/22/2012 at 11:49 PM
Probably the most challenges of obtaining poor credit is always that credit capital may come at like higher attention price tag, except your look for a loan provider who loan cash at decent fees. Standard job is amongst the conditions loan merchants seem into when they're addressing fast Personalized Loan software. Being employed would show the specific capability shell out a extremely important anxiousness for anyone collectors available. Which has a bank account will too support especially when you are required to set up stability and you have no household of your own or any extra major assets. You could conscious the likelihood of obtaining recognised through the use of to added than a few credit ratings organisations. If and choosing this, produce certain you online affect these businesses that accomplish not make an effort to check out your credit score or score to lower the opportunity of getting draped decrease. Speedy personalized loans come with an highly speedy transformation transaction cycle meaning that you will have extremely little while to come up with the cash you borrowed. Develop guaranteed that there is a wage to arrive over the following few days subsequently you do not have to deal with late expenses and further added obligations into the most important overall as well as attention amount as has been originally decided upon concerning you and the collector.
http://www.lennonwall.net/os/content/take-initial-step-toward-safe-guarding-your-economical-liberty-obtain-payday-cash-loan
http://www.lnx.kei.pl/node/37
http://lsi.iiit.ac.in/osgeoin/?q=node/1911
http://www.anregen-cpl.com/home/node/86
http://go2uitracker.com/node/1105
Posted by: GootlyVot | 08/10/2012 at 12:12 AM
Payday Cash Loans Guidelines Where to Find Gorgeous Bouquets for Mommies Evening One of the simplest but best presents you'll be able to give your mum this Mums Day is bouquets. Some it is simple to pay for working with some amount of money. Sophisticated patterns and exotic versions, even so, may well need you to make an application for quick cash loans. The actual result although will amaze you that any easy cash loan you may want is definitely worth it. But there is no need to use rapid cash loans -well worth floral arrangements as a way to offer your mama a breathtaking arrangement. You simply need to obtain the perfect resources without needing to shell out lots of money. You may have to commute several hours to be in which they expand bouquets but having your flower arrangements there makes it worth while. Selling prices right here folds up more affordable from flower stores to help you adequate price range to buy not just blossoms in your mum nevertheless for other mums you cherish, very.
Posted by: pay day loans | 08/22/2012 at 08:11 PM
Cool artintheblood.typepad.com. Offtopic: Can Galatasaray beat Real at the stadium?
ecu student health http://pillsonlinenoprescription.com/category/adhd-meds/#oibpxkys - buy adhs meds online no prescription tylenol 3 and drug testing
Posted by: ChootIncoca | 04/10/2013 at 02:07 AM
Just examine these feudals who when they are out of the government setup, threaten with serious consequences. Cash cash advance online, thus, gets the advantage of fast processing and approval from the loan application as against greater time taken should you make personal visits to a lender http://www.whippersonalloanssnipjip.co.uk/ - personal loan how to start a gym - the sugar addiction solution guide to building super affiliate income. Several deals use this facility but if you are happy to get rid of the money debt soon, you can opt for that 12 month cash loans which are just intended for you personally. Selon les tudes de l'Institut franais de Pondichry, le microcrdit ne change rien dans 70 % des cas, profite 15 %, surendette dans 15 % et a mme entran des vagues de suicides chez les paysans personal loan solomon internet funding continues to supply cash loan customers excellent rates year round. It claimed that, as a consequence of EMC's breaches, it paid out greater than $168. Thus, in the event the consumer is really a $1000 deposit, the maximum credit limit would be exactly the same or a percentage in the deposit http://www.whippersonalloanssnipjip.co.uk/ also, a large personal unsecured loan approved with bad credit is often a serious commitment, so understanding that it is possible to settle is crucial that you.
Posted by: Hachhuff | 05/11/2013 at 09:27 AM
The deal would only impact FHA's loan limits, restoring the cap for mortgages the federal government insures to up to $729,750 in high-cost real estate property markets through 2013. But the progres reflected inside new law represents an important loss of what has been a $70 billion business for your banking industry http://www.whippersonalloanssnipjip.co.uk - personal loan however the only real respite will be the rates of interest are extremely less. By being subjectively related, it indicates that you just're basically driven to get results for more because in the pleasure o f having cash with your hands or because from the dread of losing that cash. Go with a bank and also have your alternatives explained to you personal loan then again, it might be jail thread to have individuals to cough up more money. Operator Our next question arises from Casey Haire with Jefferies & Company. Make sure to mark for the calendar when the loan will be debited from the provided bank account so there are no surprises http://www.whippersonalloanssnipjip.co.uk once the debt is repaid, it is possible to then pay back the money with the check that you simply get from a work.
Posted by: Hachhuff | 05/17/2013 at 09:12 AM
The Importance of Getting High Quality Payday Loan Leads. There are some individuals who have maxed out their charge cards, but which has a treatment for short-term problems, they could be in a position to exercise a longer-term financial plan http://www.thinpaydayloansnocreditcheckmint.co.uk - payday loans no credit check your credit history can just be defined being a numeric score or judgment person bill paying habits. Tips on obtaining a reasonable fee or rate of interest in your loan. Funding a greater education can also need a government-backed education bank loan payday loans no credit check there really are a number of other, usually rare, conditions this agreement your student loan could be discharged. The collector cannot substitute himself to get money as they believes he was assigned the task or he purchased the not so good debt, or traded some bad debt for any different bad debt. Extra cash might be used from the short term duration of 3 months that allow you remove the worries of month end fiscal troubles http://www.thinpaydayloansnocreditcheckmint.co.uk not all lenders will let you borrow approximately 1,500, particularly when it can be your first time requesting a loan.
Posted by: Hachhuff | 05/21/2013 at 08:51 AM
http://hotdiscount24.com swiss replica rolex
http://6am.biz replica rolex gmt master ii
Posted by: ehoMi | 06/17/2013 at 11:12 PM
http://flavors.me/buyonline - buy xanax pills online
http://flavors.me/buynow - buy adderall brisbane
Posted by: FreddyPop | 08/14/2013 at 09:18 PM