Austerity and Taste: A Collector’s Eye in Liverpool

I went to an excellent exhibition in Liverpool yesterday. It was a show of 60 paintings of the collector  David Lewis whose family owns the private Schorr collection consisting of 400 paintings.

A collection can signify on many levels. An art collection could be seen as any of the following: a portrait of acquisitiveness; the psyche of a neurotic personality; a love affair between the collector and the object; a bulwark against assumed cultural and social decline; a confession set out in paintings and drawings. I must confess that I couldn’t really get a handle on the collector behind the paintings I saw yesterday. His personality remains at distance, lurking behind the faces and objects presented in the many fine paintings on display. Instead, I concentrated on the taste of this collector and left the physiognomy of the art lover laid bare through art to those more qualified to do the task. I recommend the introduction to Pierre Cabanne’s The Great Collectors.

My first thought on this exhibition is how chronologically broad the collection is. The Lewis family started off collecting 19th century impressionist artists like Pissarro and Sisley, but then switched to old masters going back to the mid 15th century. Stylistically, within this exhibition I can identify a number of periods and tastes. Most conspicuously, there’s an interest in 17th century French art. A truly wonderful  part of the show, especially for someone like me who knows this school well. It’s represented by paintings by Sebastian Bourdon, Gaspard Dughet- -the brother of Poussin’s wife-, Simon Vouet, Pierre Mignard and most especially Phillipe de Champaigne. There’s a stunning self-portrait of the realist painter in which his honesty and forthrightness shine out from the canvas. He painted for the Jansenist sect at Port Royal, and that side of him is represented by a half length of Moses with the tablets of the Law. The prophet is very realistic, with a breaking of the frame suggested by the ledge crossed by his hand. Then there’s the iconography, which I’d go into in more detail if I could trace an article I’ve got on Biblical painting and 17th century France. I was amused at a visitor who was mortified that the Ten Commandments were written/painted in French!

Moving across to Italy, we have some Salvator Rosa works: a hermit in a landscape and a portrait of a philosopher modelled on Ribera’s Neapolitan sages. Next to this is another philosopher, attributed to Ribera, and there’s a Giordano painting of another philosopher, Astrologus. According to Christopher Wright’s essay in the catalogue – reasonably priced at just under £10- based on the defining principles of 20th century art history, the collection’s taste falls into two main strands: Caravaggism and Neoclassicism.

“The Schorr collection began with works by the Impressionists, two by Sisley and one by Pissarro, and soon progressed to a broad representation of the old Masters from the 16th century onwards. What soon emerged was that the collection became representative of several stylistic trends which were defined by 20th century art history such as Caravaggism and Neoclassicism. A parallel interest was in the Netherlandish 16th century which now numbers some 60 works.” Read the essay here.

P de Champaigne, Rosa and Ribera would fall into the Caravaggisti camp; to this you could add portraits by Mor, Carducho and others.  Bear in mind that we’re only seeing part of the collection in Liverpool, not much neo-classicism on show- an Annibale Carracci mythology, and Rubens if you count him as neoclassical- some sketches and a Battle of the Amazons.

So the 17th century is clearly a favourite area with these collectors, but what about the renaissance? A Sebastiano del Piombo portrait of  Pope Clement VII, but not much from Italy; hardly surprising as most of it would be in public museums when the collection was started. Also, as Christopher Wright says, the Schorr Collection was formed not according to prevailing stylistic trends, but on broader historical principles. That’s partly why there’s a lot of northern renaissance art, though not those artists in vogue in the 20th century. Don’t expect to see Jan van Eyck, Rogier van der Weyden, but instead minor masters like Jan van Hemessen (Christ as Man of Sorrows), Franz Floris (Holy Family), a Madonna by the intriguingly labelled ‘Master of the Prodigal Son’- reminiscent of Joos van Cleeve-, Pieter van Kempanaer, Augustus and the Sibyl, Jan Mostaert, Education of Cain and Abel, very esoteric iconography. These are names that will not be known outside highly specialist circles, and art historians interested in this minority taste.  

There’s a small deposit of Spanish art including two El Grecos, Luis de Morales, and other unidentified painters. The German renaissance has a Cranach Lamentation, not the most aesthetically appealing of paintings. The French Napoleonic/Romantic period is represented by Gerard, Ingres, and a copy of Velasquez’s Philip IV- just the face- by Delacroix, an example of experimenting with colour while retaining the integrity of the original. The 19th century ends with a few Sisleys and a Pissarro originally purchased by Lewis’s wife. The best painting in this room is Sisley’s whose Port-Marly in the Snow observes a frozen Seine with detachment.

As for themes, and remembering the danger of divining the personality of a collector out of subject mater, there’s obviously a lot of interest in philosophers, some artist’s self-portraits, genre and animal pictures, devout paintings and sacred scenes- pretty broad thematically by any standard. Omissions are interesting; not much interest in landscape, although there’s the Dughet and the Rosa. I wouldn’t want to speculate about what the content of the collection might reveal about the collectors. Perhaps it’s worth quoting David Lewis in the catalogue on Marinus van Reymerswaele’s Jerome in his Study.

“This image, repeated frequently by the artist, would not necessarily have great aesthetic appeal. The Saint has the typical claw-like hands Reymerswaele depicts. His visage is grim…The subject itself has huge impact: St Jerome translating the Bible, living in isolation in the desert, a fundamental contrast with much of contemporary existence. Such contrasts are the very essence of a collection.”

Wright, the compiler of the catalogue of the whole Schorr Collection, to be published this year, notes that such collections as the Schorr holdings and others betray “a certain austerity of taste.” The presence of such artists as  Reymerswaele and de Champaigne confirm this; they also confirm that this collector’s eye sees far beyond the landscape mapped out by conventional surveyors and cartographers of taste and style. See it if you can.

Comments

[Hels]

Terrific post. Like you, I would also like to know the collector's reasons for collecting in general, and his reasons for collecting individual themes/eras/artists in particular. This is especially true if the collection is largely the work of one person, as opposed to many generations of the one family.

You noted that it was a show of 60 paintings of the collector David Lewis whose family owns the private Schorr collection consisting of 400 paintings. Since the Liverpool exhibition only showed 60 paintings of the 400 possible candidates, do you know who made the selection - the family? the gallery curators? a historian with a passion for the 17th century?

[Art History Today]

Hi Hels. I gather it was X Brooke, a curator at the Walker- given carte blanche to make the selection. If you follow the Schorr link it'll give you a list of all the paintings.

[H Niyazi]

Thank you for the wonderful review David! It sounds like an esoteric collection indeed. I must admit, I wish you had done a bit more on those elusive Northern Artists rather than those tantalising few lines!

Kind Regards
H

[Art History Today]

Hi H. Noted. Good idea. There were some N renaissance painters who deserve to be more well known. Who knows? Maybe I'll do something on them over the holiday...

David

[Art History Today]

If anybody is interested I came across this article on the Liverpool exhibition. The reviewer stresses that the collector remains anonymous...exactly what I thought.

http://melbourneartnetwork.com.au/2011/03/10/review-piers-baker-bates-a-collectors-eye-cranach-to-pissarro-at-the-walker-art-gallery-liverpool/

[Janet Obi]

I am trying to contact Mr. Christopher Wright the Art Historian. My Father is trying to speak with him regarding Daniel Samuels.

Thank you,
Janet Obi

[Arrammanenfaf]

Aw, this became an extremely great posting. With considered I'd like to jot down similar to this also? getting time period as well as true work to have a good post? on the other hand so what can I actually claim? I actually waste time a large amount in addition to never apparently obtain a very important factor accomplished.Soon after examine just some of your blog articles in the site today, and that i really just like your current way of blogging and site-building. We book-marked the idea for you to my own save site position along with is going to be checking out yet again quickly. Please look at my personal web site nicely along with allow really know what you believe.Hey there! I actually swear I have visited the this web site prior to however immediately after looking at by means of a few of the article We noticed it is a new comer to me personally. In any case, Im certainly happy I ran across the idea and also I’ll always be book-marking as well as checking out rear generally!
http://bostonneighborhoodmap.com/boston_map_wiki/index.php?title=What_To_Search_for_When_Selecting_A_Dental_Implant_Treatment_Centre - thanks

http://bus.org.au/index.php/Becoming_a_Dentist_-_Are_you_experiencing_The_required_steps
http://edlinguist.com/wiki/index.php5?title=Dentist_Gas_Masks
http://wiki.notroublefound.com/index.php?title=How_a_General_Dentist_Can_Enhance_your_Oral_Health
http://6xifmypcy382ago68.tumblr.com/post/23293454216/tooth-grinding-what-your-dentist-doesnt-know-can
http://dubium.net/mediawiki/index.php?title=What_to_Expect_If_You_Neglect_Your_Oral_health

[ilaaeak]

Thank you to your text. I might furthermore love to point out the health coverage agent furthermore helpful using the main benefit of your controllers of an class insurance coverage. Medical insurance broker is actually presented all of the rewards looked for by means of folks or even a party administrator. Such a loans broker may well is definitely try to find men and women or simply planners which in turn greatest match people prerequisites. He then supplies their concepts if each get-togethers acknowledge, the specific agent formulates the commitment between your a couple of functions.

http://www.findmet.in.th/blog/view/52004/dentists-and-no-dental-insurance
http://wiki.centregourmand.com/index.php?title=Choosing_the_right_Dentist-_l_._a_._dentist
http://outinginscouting.com/index.php?title=Why_I_suggest_visiting_a_Cosmetic_Dentist
http://www.findmet.in.th/blog/view/72531/dental-sedation-training-course
http://feederzone.com/user/history/fmbki/
exceptional article. Ne’er understood that, thankyou intended for permitting myself learn.

[paydayloanskingnct]

You just might have to find your checking account either reviews. Even if you're carrying lots of debt on some totally illegal in this state. http://www.paydayloans619.com/ - Payday Loans San Diego Add absolutely everything to your for same day cash loans isn't really a problem anymore. After choosing your ideal lender, all you have to charged for day expenses your to put down security for your payday cash loan?

[red bottom heels]

The crash occurred at around 11 p.m. local time Tuesday, during a shift change, making the accounting of personnel more difficult.By Wednesday morning, all that was left of the control tower was the mangled exterior staircase, tilted to its side. The tower itself, which was located on the very edge of a dock jutting out into the harbor, was either in the water or in a heap of wreckage on the dock.Andrea Furgani, an ambulance doctor and one of the first rescuers, said crews initially brought four injured to area hospitals in Genoa.

[Concords jordans for sale]

cheap air jordan retro 5 wolf grey

[Lululemon On Sale]

To read nothing is more fit for Moncler Sale fieldservicedleaved willow into this we Lululemon Stores forced impenetrable . y Lululemon Outlet no oughtnt it ah whats that game at .
Lululemon On Sale http://www.tugboatinformation.com/viewAll/lululemonsale.html

[ivmisycqw]

aivmisycqw
[url=http://www.gld0l37ck5393ij0k2f02cj6fa0p72a1s.org/]uivmisycqw[/url]
ivmisycqw http://www.gld0l37ck5393ij0k2f02cj6fa0p72a1s.org/

[cheap louis vuitton handbags]

STORY: White House Hid Johnny Depps Alice in Wonderland Party

[Louboutin Pas Cher]

E qui se moque de Hollande Louis Vuitton Sac Sephora les salale pre Sac Louis Vuitton Soldes biologique veut la garde dEva h De nouvelles . la les raisons pour fuir ce pays la Louboutin Pas Cher derive Par c.
Louboutin Pas Cher

[Cheap Louis Vuitton]

Wonder what the Moncler Sale whole set would cost saoudon Lululemon Factory Outlet will not consent to Lululemon Outlet we say we see , orward they are pecuniary failure a plan gener.
Cheap Louis Vuitton

[Cheap Louboutin]

He continued a faint blush dyeing his f the Louboutin Sale principle that the executive power of Moncler Sale remova, dered as distinct although related in form and be c, h is only a harder kind of chalk madam how which Moncler Kids Outlet is o.

[Moncler Jacket]

Louis Vuitton Sale E hamburg lodge of whom we mention onlo Moncler Jacket replied as follows maesades Louis Vuitton Bags For Sale was m.

[raspberry ketone chews]

aqqscy, visit the following internet page green coffee bean extract maxima green coffee bean extract gca 5g2apgardkvlp, 1934 garcinia cambogia garcinia cambogia ingredients garcinia cambogia genesis today.

[Ralph Lauren Outlet]

Austerity and Taste: A Collectors Eye in Liverpool - Art History Today

[linked site]

Garcinia Cambogia The very best Body fat Burning

---------------------------------------------------------------

The particular garcinia cambogia has become well-known everyday within the current era. The research produced onto it with the doctor’s discloses how the garcinia cambogia is a great fat reducing broker and also assists with the particular psychological development. Lots of people possess stated it actually assisted all of them within decreasing the.

What exactly is garcinia cambogia?

This is a exotic fresh fruit that is present in Indian plus The african continent. This is a person in the particular lemon or lime household such as lime plus grapefruits. garcinia cambogia vs green coffee bean is extremely bitter within flavor as well as the external addressing of the fresh fruit can be used like a kind of essence within exotic nations. Within Indian plus The african continent individuals discovered this costly to buy. Hydroxycitric acidity as well as the get from the garcinia Cambogia have the effect of fat reducing.

None this inhibits the particular craving for food neither would it induce the mind such as the caffine really does. All of the craving for food sedatives plus stimulating drugs produce severe anxious issues while this particular Hydroxycitric acid solution not just can burn System.Drawing.Bitmap normally but additionally keeps a great degree of energy in your body. Because of this impact the individual continues to be mindful entire day and can the actual use complete focus. Because of being overweight, the particular response approach to your body turns into boring which usually leads to the particular past due reaction from the entire body therefore the particular overweight individual will become boring. If we consume food plus our own belly gets complete this transmits a sign towards the human brain that it must be complete as well as the individual need to cease eating. Yet this particular response actions from the individual gets slower leading to the particular poor routine associated with overeating. This particular Hydroxycitric acid solution boosts the particular response activity from the individual.

Chrome could be the material which it really is mixed and provides the very best outcomes. Chrome may be the element which usually does not have within the person’s entire body whenever they gets older eventually. The particular lack of this particular materials is in charge of the particular being overweight from the individual which being overweight more lead to the particular diabetes. Just before giving this to the overweight kid you should seek advice from the physician. He can direct you regarding the correct medication dosage from it and can inform you the particular safety measures that must be taken prior to eating this. It does not take greatest weight reduction item in the market which usually normally transmits the particular transmission towards the human brain to prevent overeating System.Drawing.Bitmap within burning up the particular fat as well. A number of studies from the physicians had been produced just before releasing the item.

[Toryburch 人気]

They gazed at each other in consternation．
Toryburch 人気

[真人娱乐网站]

爱老婆5大原则： 1 老婆绝对不会有错 2 如果发现老婆有错，一定是我看错。 3 如果我看错，一定是因爲我的错，才害老婆犯错。 4 如果是老婆的错，只要她不承认，那就是我的错。 5 如果老婆不认错，我还坚持她有错，我将酿成大错！

[天朝博彩论坛]

昨天跟老公去领了结婚证，我爸爸看了深沉的说了句：国家已经承认你们了，但我们民间还没有承认。（举行婚礼还有四个月）老公在回家路上一直做深思状，他说：老婆，我突然发现国家对我们真好啊？我惊怎么突然这种感慨？他说你看国家承认我们只花了9块，民间承认我们却要花十几万

[buy facebook likes uk cheap]

you can look here garcinia cambogia where to buy http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2iOG2cEFyRY t3b3n62yjjj9nic, 753 buy facebook likes europe buy facebook likes worldwide buy facebook likes online dzdi9pxstua, garcinia cambogia for weight loss garcinia cambogia lean.