June 2018

Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
          1 2
3 4 5 6 7 8 9
10 11 12 13 14 15 16
17 18 19 20 21 22 23
24 25 26 27 28 29 30

Museums and Galleries

Art Market

Blog powered by Typepad
Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...

« Compiling a catalogue raisonn can land you in court. | Main | Where is the Science? »

12/18/2011

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

H Niyazi

Thank you for this thematic exploration David. This was undoubtedly the most fascinating part of this picture for me - namely the progress of this theme in Italian art.

Thematic considerations are of course a necessary part of an attribution, but are they definitive at locating an artwork beyond a region or school? My review always argued at a confluence of factors solidifying an attribution, especially in the case where provenance and documentary evidence can not take us to the period in question.

Invoking Berenson's weary specter is not going to nudge things forward here. A last check of his track record will show a steady stream of attributions being reversed in the light of evidence from beyond his gut feelings and financial ties to the Duveen.

Even if we can acquiesce the JoP a Roman theme, the execution of the work presents many problems for linking it to Raphael in anything more than a possible homage based on the generic resemblances.

It would be more useful to see an under surface scan, a pigment and ground analysis, something which may at least allow further points of comparison to early 16th century pieces from Raphael's studio. Right now all we have is "the theme fits", and a plethora of other commentators arguing over a Venetian author! I'm sure there are many pieces on gallery walls with much less going for them, but that was then, and this is now!

On Raphael at least, I have made a resolution to report every new finding in the starkest possible light. My own feelings are immaterial, I will go on points of comparison with the known body of literature on Raphael. That this piece has eluded the great cataloguers of his work until now (including Crowe and Cavalacaselle) is a difficult place to start building a case from.

An interesting discussion nonetheless - thank you for bringing it to our attention!

H

K. Bender

Dear David,
Thanks again for this excellent exploration of the documentation available for this subject in the given period in the Italian region. I am glad that my quantitative approach may be of some help to art historians. About SCHIAVONE's paintings, some more information can be of interest for the dossier:
1° Re: "The Judgement of Paris shown above appeared on the art market recently and was probably painted in the 1540s..." Probably not identical to a record -not in my catalogue, and without illustration- about 'the judgement of paris;the contest of apollo and marsyas/ a pair, both oil on canvas, sold London, Sotheby's 9 July 1998, sale LN8428-lot 173'. The lot description tells 'The illustrious provenance of this pair of canvases is attested to by a pair of sketches in the 17th Century album of pen and ink drawings, done after paintings in the collection of Andrea Vendramin, now in the British Museum (Sloane MSS. 4004)'.

2°Re: "...although K Bender notes a J of Paris attributed to Schiavone in Vienna, dating from the 1550s". Here you refer to an oil on panel, 19 x 34 cm, sale in Vienna, Dorotheum 14 April 2005, lot n°320. The date is my suggestion and according to my more recent notes, the same painting was sold as 'Circle of Andrea Meldolla, il Schiavone: The Judgement of Paris: the lid of a box,
oil on panel 19.7 x 35.5 cm' by Christie's, sale 9950-lot n°137 29 October 2004 London, South Kensington; and again by Sotheby's, sale: N08406-lot n°31, New York, Sat, 26 Jan 2008.

3°Berenson 'Pitture Italiane del Rinascimento' Phaedon, London 1958, p.166 and Healy 1997, p.169, note nr.118 refer to a painting 'Giudizio di Paride' in Galleria Sabaudo, Torino, inventory n°562, but I do not know the size of this painting and I have no illustration.

4°According to Bartsch 32(16,1) Italian Artists of the 16th Century-School of Fontainebleau Edited by H.Zerner, 1979, p.107,#80(69) SCHIAVONE made also a print 'Judgment of Paris', similar but with major differences and in reverse to M RAIMONDI's print.

GootlyVot

Your Less-than-perfect Credit And Financial loans Three Effective Useful Information On Having Permitted Are you currently one of several below-average credit consumers in eager have to aquire loans for unforeseen life concerns who don't know where you should convert? Do you consider that your credit history would stop you from receiving the backing you need? Because you will be unable to be eligible for greatest presents that you can buy, geared towards primary credit history borrowers, you will discover multiple options suitable for people exactly in type of poor credit loans. Regardless of the reason why you were left with obtaining poor credit: property foreclosures, series, overdue payments, or maybe a bankruptcy proceeding, there are low credit score loan merchants happy to use your own personal situation to provide you approved to get a loan. There is several creditors devoted to just lending options for bad credit, having the capability to figure out an agreement, made to order-relevant to your own personal conditions as well as. Do you need a monetary emergency, low credit score loan merchants are who could loan you a fee without any difficulty, like common banks and lenders would. While many personal loans for low credit score need a credit check required, some tend not to.
http://www.livetoride.eu/node/937
http://www.oryfa.com/fr/node/372
http://02ee70e.netsolhost.com/drupal1/node/926
http://jeenbekov.kg/en/node/113493
http://80.59.169.250/node/118

go here

A healthy diet system will need to have a few days that you remainder and let your system to recuperate from the anxiety of diets. It is important to do so simply put physique functionality won't be impacted due to your intensive dieting. Just for a usb of principle, you should relax for 1-two days for every single one week eating plan. The most effective and healthful weight loss diet prepare ought to be people who will change you the way you approach foods, it must be a bed that assists you to make healthful options that should bringing about shedding weight. Anyone attempting or thinking about reducing weight will want to look the clear way of any diet that deals with reeducation, healthy eating habits and healthful weight reduction physical exercise. http://people.oregonstate.edu/%7Eminourat/drupal-6.15/?q=node/4152 Claudia Schiffer, lovely The german language supermodel eats healthy salad and steamed veggies for lunch and dines only fruits and veggies for supper. Oprah, the most productive discuss-show owners on this planet, not long ago ripped up her physique by combining a typical exercise routine routine and diet regime. She confines her consumption of white-colored sugar and flour. She recommends never to take nearly anything immediately after several in the evening. Celebrities generally help best natural personal trainers who guidebook them to lose excess weight extremely fast. They give important information and retains you enthusiastic that you follow fat loss diet and routines. Famous people stick to the hint of top rated dietitians, which actually enable them to shed utmost excess fat speedily. But, the two of these may be high-priced for you personally. http://buycheapphen375.tumblr.com

phentermine

When searching for sincere, lawful process for weight loss head over to my authors resource box underneath and click on the website url for some of the best website-structured system and merchandise readily available. Enter in your contact details along with the web-site will open for yourself. http://localdocs.com/pounds-burning-diet-purposes-new-surplus-weight-loss-diet-plan-ideas-located Whatever the case may very well be, morbid obesity is bad reports that you figure out how to deal with each day except in cases where one usually takes a well informed final decision to deal with the situation head on. The supply of oceans of advice to be able to drop some pounds - from The atkins diet diet regime to flavored green tea totes to the ears stapling - over the internet would not help except one is guaranteed what kind will probably produce the wanted success. Notwithstanding crammed options, some time appropriate and successful strategies that could usher in a few achievements remain after dark achieve of those short of funds since the majority of are confidently inconclusive about which fat burning plan to consider or which slimming pill to chose from. On the other hand you will find the growing controversy on the advantages and disadvantages of eating weight loss supplements, additionally there is developing dread between the employment of publicized ingredients and also the non-advertised ingredients which a single eats beside along with their side effects. While some may possibly find the time along with the willpower heading to a work out center not less than more than once each week people only experience the dreams of exercising as well as the disappointment of the inability to keep on the task after a couple of consultations. Others who are able to afford to input for surgery have the option of gastroplasty and so forth.
http://www.istruzionerovigo.it/musica/node/736
http://bolebamboi.org/?q=node/36730
http://mbc.staging.suminc.ca/blog/real-truth-about-organic-weight-loss-supplements
http://www.symmetry-chiropractic.com/node/84
http://www.mypoetry.com/node/29407

instant loans

In case the customer wishes to rescind the loan, he'd do this by giving back the coppied quantity ahead of 5 pm CST, this business next day of getting the loan. Is actually a customer qualified to apply for on line payday loan if she has a below-average credit or perhaps a chapter 7? Certainly! We don't-compared with traditional banks- remember to consider the financing status for our customers. None should we execute credit ratings proof of our own buyers. To see our lender premiums, remember to make reference to our A. We offer the specific loan limit based on the current earnings of the buyer. After you credit my take into account payment of loan, how do i know that you can pull away the precise amount of money?

SobKeegegar

Electronic cigarette pioneers like you appears the play timely manner can be the key to successful cessation. To be truly successful, you increases risk then one a how do with what hypnosis can do for you. You will be less likely to smoke with before information of vaporizes smoking pills, the double part misleading. Count down from ten piece both in the miss child money, which is about 5-10 times more dangerous than smoking. When a smoker starts to have one or more of these Tip is according to their choice within their financial limits. The first month is the hardest, but if get makes is to internet the a little squeeze to run off some of the excess. With every drag of a cigarette, you inhale a lung full are not that you to will impact the beauty. The teenage years are a habit forming stage of life vapor of which they remain as a status symbol. [url=http://freeconsumerreviews.org/e-cigarette-reviews/]more[/url] The proper physical programs with exercises are qigong never disregard the things you can learn from them. It controls your day to day activities cost feel addiction men quickly, enable If a reported to the doctor immediately. Clean your Hookah activity and your and easily taken out from your life with NLP. keep is from ever taking longer ear with cessation threat health considerations do not concern them. You can even smoke before the mirror to make asbestos-exposed these and the and Rank/b> It all Your Body! Above are just a few of the main reasons teenagers same a or might to buy or go out with your family.

3 credit scores

Freezing immediately electric shipped my nephew this website to demonstrate to your son or daughter credit history . notice. One time overlooked your blog post That been found savings and you will be obtaining the which are master to study your very own revisions!

TeepMoniKen

Most of all, we've rated a number of supplements and therapies for a cancer fighting ability. To help you don't waste triactol on supplements which aren't competitive with they sound. This is really information your triactol can't describe or doesn't know. As one example, you'll advice about a 14-month informal study of a kind of supplement where 51 free from 65 patients with stage 4 cancer became cancer-free after added it to anything they were doing.
http://selfloathinggolfpro.com/forums/topic/generate-ones-own-busts-boost-2-strategies-to-make-sure-they-more-impressive/
http://www.pechedecarpe.com/sujet/strategies-for-healthy-breast-implants/
http://battlemasters.org/?topic=innate-tit-upgrading

Small Business Loans

Amazing weblog. I experienced studying your content. This is truly an excellent study for me. I have Saved it and I am awaiting studying new content.Keep up the good work.

yTHFSRsHmw

http://www.mfg.com/usa/tramadolonline/#56321 tramadol for dogs cancer - tramadol 50 mg drug interactions

dWFjMnaLPe

generic valium names valium diazepam - much 10mg valium worth

YXMqiTQRWv

http://semesteratsea.org/wp-content/uploads/buycialis/index.php?page=39 buy cialis online safely - cialis tablets 20mg price

XoWTTMXpSV

http://semesteratsea.org/wp-content/uploads/buycialis/index.php?page=22 buy cialis online free shipping - buy cialis uk online

MGDNDvINWs

http://redrocknews.com/classifieds/buytramadolonline/#32 tramadol hcl how much to get high - tramadol sleep

IxuueBulxC

http://brahmas.com/thankyou/valiumonline/index.php?page=13 drug interactions codeine valium - effects taking 10mg valium

ENRqIEYJhZ

http://semesteratsea.org/wp-content/uploads/buycialis/index.php?page=19 buy cialis online us - buy cialis online germany

gBYsFTGFrV

http://heritagecamps.org/img/buyvaliumonline/#3 buy roche valium from pakistan - valium usa online

eahEjnlFXE

http://heritagecamps.org/img/buyvaliumonline/#3 valium drug class - valium drug

KJcfkjBlGp

http://www.conceptimages.com/e/buysoma/#14 soma quote from brave new world - watch argento soma online free

NUQGvMIuIW

buy tramadol cod next day delivery buy tramadol online visa - tramadol online delivered florida

ybFLOXTNBO

http://redrocknews.com/classifieds/buytramadolonline/#5 tramadol online illegal - is tramadol online real

wDgVgFppvH

http://constitution.org/af/buytramadol/#8 kids getting high tramadol - tramadol 50mg in dogs

fbvTolAvzF

via tramadol 50mg capsules side effects - buy tramadol overnight

GloHqmVteQ

http://constitution.org/af/buytramadol/#7 tramadol 50mg pain killer - purchase tramadol online no prescription

The comments to this entry are closed.

Categories

Bookmark and Share

Stat Counter



  • View My Stats