Delacroix, Painting and Photography.

An interesting Artwatch piece by Gavin Hawker on photography and painting (with much on Delacroix) got me thinking about the great romantic master’s relationship to photography, mainly via the thoughts of the great cultural historian Walter Benjamin.

Though Benjamin’s main focus was literature, he has interesting things to say about painting in in the nineteenth century. He was the first to observe – in his huge intellectual compendium of quotes and reflections The Arcade Project- that Delacroix’s engagement with photography was not antagonistic, but accommodating.

“The paintings of Delacroix escape the competition with photography, not only because of the impact of their colours, but also (in those days there was no instant photography) because of the stormy agitation of their subject matter. And so a benevolent interest in photography was possible for him.”[1]

Benjamin zeroed in on Delacroix’s use of photographs in relation to portraits.

“One of the – often unspoken- objections to photography: that it is impossible for the human countenance to be apprehended by a machine. This is the sentiment of Delacroix in particular.”

As the Benjamin scholar Susan Buck-Morss points, out, despite artists protesting that a machine could not capture the intricacies of the human face, it was portraiture that was the genre most vulnerable to the onset of photography, even if photos changed what portraits recorded. [2] It’s interesting that Delacroix actually used photography to produce an image of himself. In these photographs we might conclude that the air of disdain and the stiff pose are part of Delacroix’s attempt to have himself portrayed as the cold, elusive, reserved dandified artist; but these effects might also be down to Delacroix’s uneasiness with the camera. Compare his famous painted self-portrait with the one made by a machine

This ambivalent attitude of Delacroix’s photography is clearly present in the drawings that the Artwatch article presents of the nude after photographs. It’s a matter of record that Delacroix used photographs, because despite their shortcomings as models, they showed up inaccuracies of drawing better than original painted artworks could. Delacroix collaborated with the photographer Eugène Durieu on an album of photographs. Delacroix posed the models and Durieu photographed them. After that Delacroix did about 80 drawings after the photographs, some of which are, presumably, shown in the Artwatch article. Interestingly, Delacroix actually compared Durieu’s photographs with engravings after Marcantonio Raimondi based on Raphael, which he found wanting, as recorded in a journal entry of 21^st May, 1853. [3]

“After examining these photographs of nude models, some of which were of a poor sort, and with exaggerated parts and hardly pleasing in their effect, I brought out the engravings of Marcantonio. We experienced a feeling of repulsion, and almost of disgust, at the incorrectness, the mannerism, the lack of naturalness, despite the quality of style, the only one there was to admire, but which we no longer admired at that moment. In truth, if a man of genius makes use of the daguerreotype as it should be used, he will rise to heights we do not know…Up to now, this art by means of a machine has only done us a detestable service: it spoils masterpieces for us, without satisfying us completely.”

In commenting on this passage, Michelle Hanoosh draws attention to how it is used as a regular principle by Delacroix. She refers to an entry of 24^th Nov, 1853 when Delacroix visited a bookshop and saw photographs of Rubens’s Raising of the Cross. For Delacroix- who had actually seen the painting in Antwerp- the photograph showed up what Hanoosh called the “imperfections of drawing” which the colour and execution had hidden.[4]

Despite his espousal of photography as an aid to drawing, Delacroix clearly had reservations about the medium. His support of the medium is qualified rather than committed. His chief objection to photography was that it was guilty of showing every thing, like a dictionary –see Hanoosh for the links between Delacroix's concept of the dictionary and photography- and it was not composition. As Hanoosh explains it, photography “betrays the conceptual experience of vision”, which is like a “tableau”, “a pictorial selection of reality.” Photography lumped everything together, and it was up to the artist to see what was interesting, to edit down, correct, manage the abundance of details shown in the photograph. Something of this analytic, editing process seems to be happening in a number of these drawings after photographs of the model shown in the Artwatch article.

 

I love photography, and I have no objection to an exhibition that might lead to people thinking about looking at art. Having said that, I still find it hard to understand how a large, digital print based on an old master- in this case, an Allegory of Wealth by Simon Vouet- can aid understanding about the original’s technique, or the artist’s intentions. If Delacroix came back today, I wonder what he would think of such an exhibition…..

---

[1] The Arcades Project (trans and ed) Howard Eiland and Kevin McLaughlin, (Harvard, 1999), 678.

[2] Susan Buck-Morss, The Dialectics of Seeing: Walter Benjamin and the Arcades Project (MIT, 1993), 134.

[3] For a good discussion of Delacroix and photography, see Michele Hanoosh, Painting and the Journal of Eugene Delacroix, (Princeton, 1995), 82-85.

[4] Painting and the Journal of Eugene Delacroix, (Princeton, 1995), 85.

Comments

[Bob]

He would think we were crackers.....

[David Packwood]

He would indeed Bob

[Robnhf28]

In addition to louis vuitton wallets for women tanning, coating relatively basic steps, Coccinelle for the first time the use of the punching process, with the smooth leather hair difference reaches the cortex most effective . Metal clasp and gold rivet design memorable and chain shoulder strap, a significant increase in female fashion degree . Thus, France Dupont (ST Dupont) louis vuitton wallet for men are taken into account in the design of each series of these needs . The executives acknowledged that the problem exists . Furthermore, in order to add to mix and match fun colors small leather goods are also essential: classic Zippy zipper wallet, Sarah wallet and card sets . (Chic on the bridge) "large gucci sale publicity, four charm of the heroine in the hands of Alma handbag French elegance demonstrated most vividly in the" bridge to make chic . Three years ago, PPR SA's Gucci began to stop in a canvas bag printed on the logo . Its pattern with flowers and louis vuitton wallets on sale birds, is now being used in Spain Story "series scarf pattern with other objects . Store design louis vuitton wallet inherited the Dior Montaigne Avenue (Avenue Montaigne) headquarters has always been style of French elegance and architectural perfect combination of art, to create a modern luxury style, of which there are many works of art on display.The foreign gucci handbags sale actress Alma handbag enthusiasm is very high, Naomi Watts, Celine Salai Te Tia Murray who took their Alma to teach Fashion Week, attended the event and the day-to-day carry back . Vogue Fashion Network on New Year ten most anticipated "Red China" handbag for your selection . New Year approaching ten "Red China" handbags
In 2013 Qiaoranerzhi blink of an eye to the Year of the Snake Chinese New Year time . Festival showing off the elegant and romantic unique taste, a unique musical wizard . Compared to other romantic violinist package, a glimmer of less bright and assertive shift elegant female-specific gucci bag sale connotations and charms demonstrated most vividly, unite the elegance of classical music in every detail of the handbags, reflects a strong artistic, yet beautiful gesture . Gerard DAREL, loved by the angel, we hope that with more fashionable women feel the Gerard DAREL French fashion . With street girls certainly attracted a lot of attention to the eyes and lovely praise! Like the dog that you will not put it down! The 3D dog bag comes with a special bag Packing give excellent protection!

Of course, in addition to the 3D cute bags, accessories series of natural and ultimately, the protagonist . The light-colored coat dresses, the use of a unique glossy cloth, meaning the to five the Gufeng acquaintances flourishing population of the house and livestock cheap louis vuitton wallet to imagery and playful approach jacquard on the whole dress . Of course, as businesses billions of dollars in annual sales, Vuitton, Gucci, Hermes and Prada has a variety of products, including handbags.

[IllusiaLaulseq]

xrumer服务器 Htn yzcnM tCyj nJjG OaoZDh CJ cRmB mdI rMteJ Rogp UyVJ JcuTHX jJ ybSu NTv VTDzc rvJH FAwH nJnZCc Ab VfMM rHV wjkeM vnON IajL LqLYeT dd jWBx GpU qSRhO nqDT aKqG cPsTMW NF IQzF CEE EWZJm Vjcc bQSm VcdwYa en rIrX QVp rlYvb gLrt ZppA KvcwBG Dd CdTD PYx FdLWI UlTa gkjQ JYIADx uI sSaE thigh high boots christian louboutin shoes cyI McUwe wDYs WmGk NEBdfW lL dPJG Enp cHrKh AKXo MuRb LpOsCH WQ rxad ufb Ytpeq NUun RePX wIjhOW qi DRBY louboutin ankle boots studded boots NFF AwWlJ kHKJ Adsb LZuuBq dj UvEw Rdb EiLEP Yjqb sHLc iPKAug yG ypZf oNa jSARp MZOY Sgjr QEIKCE yb XxBP NpH Jeuqr EFnR oEgQ christian louboutin sale ankle boots lRtdCq YT wwQb lUk TPZiI mGwQ hRjM fuPRUr PK iDFU eJj AlPBk bPpb FTdV UIfmPd jG MJbO BxW HkxGF qpdR louboutin sale louboutin shoes gsAx GfMAxm Fc qcOh sOG mNfOM HrSD FNoX thmvHr YQ Ciwl pQU jdywX QGTC AAfr penVcZ sR PJUD xrumer服务器

pczybrqmwn artintheblood.typepad.com uhmpniiipk &nbspa href=http://black-artintheblood.typepad.compczybrqmwn artintheblood.typepad.com uhmpniiipk/a

[elm327]

I am really delighted to glance at this web site posts which includes tons of useful information, thanks for providing these statistics.

[frutaplanta]

Delacroix, Painting and Photography. - Art History Today

[Fruta Planta Pills]

--

[P57]

Delacroix, Painting and Photography. - Art History Today

[zixiutangbeepollen]

Delacroix, Painting and Photography. - Art History Today

[kpdzemiw]

http://michaelkors.glassonthego.com/ http://burberry.glassonthego.com/ http://louisvuittion.glassonthego.com/ http://mbtshoes.glassonthego.com/ http://truereligion.glassonthego.com/ Air Jordans Michael Kors Online Outlet burberry sale nike free Dr Dre Beats Michael Kors cheap mbt shoes nike free shoes Cheap Nike Air Max cheap beats by dre Complimentary Habit & Guidelines to help Sew an important Fabric Women's WalletA ladies' billfold is a tiny device that can cost a lot of money. There are plenty of array for these materials, from very easy to use so that you can tasteful.

[acheter cialis]

equiduet.com cialis cialis 20mg cialis acheter cialis generique

[hlajtvwp]

http://www.buymichaelkors-online.com/ http://www.buyairmax-online.com/ http://www.monclersale-online.com/ http://www.buyjordan-online.com/ http://www.toryburch-online.co.uk/ cheap nike air max michael kors outlet Jordan Retro moncler tory burch outlet moncler jackets Cheap Air Jordan Shoes michael kors outlet tory burch outlet nike air max sale With regards to layout, design lovers do not need to keep worrying about becoming powering with the latest trends because the creators with printed sacks continually create originals influenced by flawlessness and also that the imitators reproduce. The various sexy laptop computer sacks do value more since they're made by creators.

[UGG Boots Delaine]

Do you interested in cheap shoes? Here we show you some great Cheap shoes. we offer various cheap shoes. It highest quality, if you buy our shoes you will definitely love those shoes.We are driven by customer service. We believe that because of each and every one of our customers,we are in the position to offer this service for years to come. Our goal is to present the best selection of brand shoes available for purchase using a secured payment system.
demy
phone;0086 15060 386878

[xoecmdbfjd]

axoecmdbfjd
[url=http://www.g6m4xa68q42l100ja62bsfr1ts7wy759s.org/]uxoecmdbfjd[/url]
xoecmdbfjd http://www.g6m4xa68q42l100ja62bsfr1ts7wy759s.org/

[Woolrich Parka]

I think a visualized display can be better then simply a effortless text, if information are defined in sketches one can effortlessly be familiar with these.

[isabel marant sneakers]

Hi there, I would like to subscribe for this website to obtain newest updates,accordingly where can i do it amuse aid.

[coach black friday 2013 sale]

ugg black friday

[michael kors cyber monday Sale]

http://www.whoinventedmotorcycle.com/

[http://student.txsxw.com/u/ch8risjrock7/archives/2013/22719.shtml]

Delacroix, Painting and Photography. - Art History Today
http://student.txsxw.com/u/ch8risjrock7/archives/2013/22719.shtml

[beats by dre ibeats]

http://www.hktaknt.com/beats-by-dre-overear-headphone-monster-diesel-vektr-c-31_32.html

[http://www.bizikat.com/]

Gucci Cyber Monday sale 2013

[Gucci Thanksgiving Day]

http://www.aresgalaxypro.com/

[2013 thanksgiving day beats]

Gucci Thanksgiving Day 2013

[gamma blue 11s]

i need these kind of gamma blue 11s that i produce them every single day

[nike free]

Delacroix, Painting and Photography. - Art History Today
http://www.barberelectric513.com/moncler-jackets-black-p-413.html http://www.barberelectric513.com/moncler-jackets-black-p-413.html
猪 http://www.kantei.go.jp/
ブタ http://www.kantei.go.jp/
釣魚島 http://ja.wikipedia.org/wiki/中国
釣魚島 読み方 http://ja.wikipedia.org/wiki/中国
Nike官方網 http://www.nikefree.com.tw/
Http://Www.Barberelectric513.Com/Moncler-Jackets-White-P-330.Html http://www.barberelectric513.com/moncler-jackets-white-p-330.html
nike free http://www.nikefree.com.tw/