Gombrich, Magic and World Art

(What follows is developed from a series of seminars on world art and civilizations in the Vatican museums, as well thinking about teaching world art. It turned out to be rather longer than I’d planned, once I’d warmed to my theme! Still, I haven’t posted substantially in ages.)

What is world art? When did it become a category in art history? Nowadays, visitors to museums are unlikely to be surprised at encountering statues from Egyptian tombs, Mesoamerican figurines, or ceremonial masks from Africa and Oceania, sometimes in exhibitions next to old masters. But art from non-Western cultures, as pointed out by Andre Malraux, only began to enter the world’s museums from the early years of the twentieth century. This coincided with the interest in so-called “primitivism” on the part of modern artists like Derain, Matisse and of course Picasso. The appearance of masks in such early twentieth-century masterpieces as his Demoiselles d’Avignon testifies to trips to ethnological museums in Paris to see “Negro Art.” Later, world art started to appear in surveys of art history. Even the late renaissance scholar Ernst Gombrich’s best seller The Story of Art contains illustrations of non-Western art such as Maori, Tahitian, Aztec, and Mayan art in its opening chapter; though unsurprisingly most of the book is devoted to post-classical and renaissance art.

Since Gombrich, many surveys of world art have appeared. A good example is Hermann Leicht’s History of the World’s Art (1963) which opens with “Art of the Ice Age” before going on to sweep majestically through the art of Africa, Australia and Oceania, Amerindian Art, the Near East, India, China, Japan before setting course for Egypt, Greece, Rome and the post classical world of art. [1] Leicht called his book a History of the World’s Art, and this is the kind of journey visitors are encouraged to make- both physically and virtually- through our monumental museums. Interestingly, Gombrich chose to name his book The Story of Art. This was an inspired choice as “Story” immediately brings to mind tales told round the camp fire, the oral tradition, a sense of art handed down rather than an organized systematic overview of the progress of the world’s civilizations which is the kind of universal cultural history promoted through the museum. Though the lion’s share of Gombrich’s book is given over to that history of western art, Gombrich was not oblivious of world cultures which is borne out by his preamble where he considers the way that cave paintings, ritual masks, Aztec carvings and other artifacts of early civilizations operate on the viewer’s mind. [2] In exploring these cultures Gombrich places great emphasis on magic, which he sees encoded in the ritualistic art of early peoples, their tribal customs and totems signifying deep patterns of thought incomprehensible to the modern mind. Rather than try to locate the art of early civilizations in some linear account of its history like Leicht, where after the Ice Age, art readies itself for the “ascent towards civilization, “Gombrich voyages leisurely to these disparate cultures with the aim of discovering how their art works, “wether it can perform the required magic” as opposed to simply representing such notions as the “beautiful.” What Gombrich seems to be doing here is defining ancient art in terms of process in art creation. Gombrich invites us to return to ourselves by making doodles of a face; this may be merely amusing to us, but to an ancient tribesman, it would have been a way of constructing identity out of the forms around him, and thus making cognitive sense of the world. An ancient artist in discovering the ways of creating art may indeed have looked upon this discovery as something magic, almost indistinguishable from the skill and craftsmanship which brought it into being.

This picture-making power certainly reflects the artist’s skill, but when we re-frame artistic ability within the narrative of how western civilization evolved, that magical dimension seems to disappear, or at least it is subsumed within such ineffable ideas as “genius” which, arguably, is the magic concept applied to technical skill and ingenuity?

One of the reasons why the magical aspect of art is absent from art history narratives is due to what the archaeologist Colin Renfrew calls the “tyranny of the Renaissance.” [3] Our notions of style and taste have been shaped by the Greco-Roman world to such a large extent that the arts of remote cultures like the Maya and Polynesians have not been appreciated until very recently, because we have not been able to accommodate them within our canons of beauty and taste, which are based on renaissance standards. It is interesting, and this attests to Gombrich’s intellectual generosity, that such an established Renaissance expert as himself was immune to this “tyranny of the Renaissance” and knew how magic and myth underpinned the art of the classical period that was responsible for giving the renaissance its cultural direction. Very few renaissance art historians stop to consider how magic or the “primitive” informed the practices of artists and the patrons associated with the canon of Roman copies of Greek sculpture found in such volumes as Haskell and Penny’s Taste and Antique. [4] From studying such books we might form the idea that the religion of the ancient Romans was rational and moral, mediated through anthropomorphism, or the allocation of human qualities to divine forces; but in fact that came later in the Roman’s cultural development. Long before Rome had even begun to conceive of world domination, it was a collection of tribes reliant on a religious system based on a balance between humanity and divine powers rather than a mythology embodied in a pantheon of deities dressed up in elegant garments. [5] Rome’s ancestral origins provide fertile soil for the excavation and retrieval of cultic and tribal ideas.

The Etruscans, supposedly the mythic founders of Rome, who would have dwelled in Neolithic mud huts, had the legend of Romulus and Remus suckled by the She-Wolf, an important iconic bronze statue donated to the people of Rome. Unlike Haskell and Penny who mainly consider the critical fortunes of the She-Wolf, Gombrich focus is on how the statue may indicate anthropological links between tribes who named themselves after animals, a “wolf-tribe,” as opposed to a frog or raven tribe, or similar. Though we don’t dress ourselves up as animals anymore, or even register the superstitious links between zoology and art, Gombrich believed that we can at least attempt to cloak ourselves mentally within ancient civilizations. By donning this mentality we might understand the image of say, a serpent in ancient Mexican art, and the picture/art-making process behind it in terms of magic and religion. Gombrich would quietly assimilate his ideas on magic and image within his book on the psychology of perception ten years later, where he discusses, amongst others: the idea of the “animal shape” within the cave painting of Lascaux; Egyptian sculpture in the context of “Pygmalion’s Power”, where an artist has to restrain himself from making the final touch lest the art come to life; the evil eye as reflected in the pictures that follow the spectators with their eyes in picture galleries, with their modern variants in advertising.

Unlike Gombrich, the anthropological adventures of Aby Warburg, his colleague and mentor, have proved more controversial. Indeed, Warburg’s own representation of himself in cowboy costume amongst the Hopi Indians in a well-known photograph has served to reinforce anxieties about how marginal cultures are constructed through the strategies of the oppressor, for example in the last post where 17th century views of cannibals are dependent upon renaissance ideas of anatomy and proportion. This has been demonstrated by Claire Farrago who alludes to this image of Warburg reproduced on the dust jacket of a book of his American photographs, which bears the title Photographs at the Frontier, and which to her suggests that modernity is “incapable of divesting its former colonial ideology.” Warburg’s highly visible ethnological project has proved unsustainable, not least because art historians are more sensitive to colonialism and histories of oppression within the era of globalisation. Gombrich’s account is far more sympathetic to ancient civilisations and it shows how it is possible to sensitively incorporate world art within art history paradigms, without mainly resorting to the ethnological and anthropological.

Themes of magic and perception, as evoked through world art, has had little impact on contemporary art history practice. Perhaps the main problem is “primitivism” which is such a loaded word, that it is either avoided completely in discussions of visual art in the classroom, or when used so qualified as to be meaningless. Magic seems particularly absent in the practices of modern museums due to the attitudes of curators who seem unaware of its significance. This problem was clearly on Gombrich’s mind since in Art and Perception, he drew on Andre Malraux’s belief that the modern museum has created a different “mental set” where the public are encouraged to see art as “species” rather than as indicators of a vitalizing force possessing great reserves of power. The recognition of this mental set is thwarted by the constraints of modern museums. For reasons of conservation we are, quite rightly, instructed not to touch objects, but that distancing moves us away from the atavistic, originary contexts of this art, especially if it is world art. Yet the situation is more complex than this because according to Gombrich there never was a “primitive stage of man where all was magic,” neither was there “an evolution that wiped out the earlier phase.” Instead, in museums and institutions these mental sets consisting of older, atavistic ideas evoked unconsciously by art and the newer ways, associated with modern museum practice, tend to overlap. As the guide takes us round a highly organised hang of painted portraits, we might have the uneasy feeling of the eyes following us, of the picture possessing something of the actualising Pygmalion life-force.

Wether this is “magic” in any traditional sense is open to question, but it does raise the question of how we should weave magic associated with the cultures of the world into the display programmes of institutions like the British Museum and the Vatican. How might the mental set operate, for example, when looking at this crucifix from Zaire, now housed in the Vatican. The Vatican curators treat it as an ethnological object, but when we learn that with the decline in importance of the religious missions, the cross transmogrified into a protective spirit (Nkangi kiditu), as well as a symbol for the chief of the tribe, we start to appreciate how complex our engagement with this art should be. We should also begin to wonder if Gombrich’s magic theme is more relevant to our appreciation of world art like this, rather than the grand, evolutionary schemes underwritten by narratives of scientific and rational progress, and so favoured by museums and institutions today

---

[1] Hermann Leicht, History of the World’s Art (1963).

[2] Ernst Gombrich, The Story of Art (1950, rep. 1984), 19-30.

[3] Colin Renfrew, Figuring It Out: The Parallel Visions of Artists and Archaeologists, (2003), 58-64.

[4] Francis Haskell and Nicholas Penny, Taste and the Antique: The Lure of Classical Sculpture 1500-1900, (1981).

[5] Michel Grant, The History of Rome (1978), 19-20.

Comments

[Womens Uggs Classic Tall Dylyn 1001204 Jacket Boots]

Mens Uggs 5523 Sneakers http://www.savageye.com

[Canadian Coat Feather]

Apart from many face washing all through every day, I didn't understand what else to endeavor to support my skin dysfunction. Laying within the lavatory sink's edge, was a tube of Dr. Sheffield's Diaper Rash Ointment.
Canadian Coat Feather http://www.uangsuper.com/canadian-coat-feather

[barbour jacket]

http://www.sayidointhegarden.com barbour outlet http://www.sayidointhegarden.com barbour jacket http://www.sayidointhegarden.com barbour sale http://www.haskoningng.com/ www.haskoningng.com

[新疆时时彩走势]

平安夜的每一朵雪花飘下，每一个烟火燃起，每一秒时间流动，每一份思念传送。都代表着我想要送你的每一个祝福！

[澳门足球]

假如我是诗人，我将以满腔的热情写下万千诗篇，赞美我亲爱的老师。我是一个诗人吗？不是，所以只能借这条短信表达我的祝福：节日快乐！

[piumini moncler]

"Don't get involved unless the problem is disruptive to you or the household," she suggests. "If you do, make the consequence related to the problem. If arguing about clothes makes them late for school, they can't borrow anything for two weeks."

[gvbslhyx]

agvbslhyx
[url=http://www.gmj876ui7r6ieob9pv3342mz5jn32753s.org/]ugvbslhyx[/url]
gvbslhyx http://www.gmj876ui7r6ieob9pv3342mz5jn32753s.org/

[COACH F15455 SVGAR / / /]

http:/thewellbookshop.com/news/Default.asp?id=218/buy replica rolex watches
COACH F15455 SVGAR / / /

[ugg boot liners]

This shape, the roomiest and most calm, is most effective should you switch or shift inside your rest. Nonetheless, the bags' roomier inside indicates they are not as heat as other designs and can be rather bulky. Good examples incorporate the Woods Rectangular Sleeping Bag through the Canadian Tire Company, along with the Sleepcell 5 lb.
ugg boot liners

[cheap nfl jerseys for sale]

The professional wholesale nfl nike jerseys in china which shop for jerseys for men women and youth. All of jerseys are in high quality and competitive prices.

[最好的博彩]

1、屁股的皮肤比脸蛋光滑，别看脸蛋用这个蜜那个霜的。一小瓶就要好几百甚至上千。但是屁股什么霜都不用照样光滑如镜。2、屁股不容易起皱纹，人一过四十有皱纹是免不了的，但大都集中在脸上，屁股上有吗？至少我没见到过。所以屁股比脸蛋更青春靓丽。3、屁股上没有乱七八糟的东西，什么粉刺啊，青春豆啊，这都与屁股无关。4、屁股的造型好看，简简单单的就两块肉，符合当今社会所崇尚的简约的时尚！5、屁股比脸蛋严肃更有官威，当官最大的基本功就是喜怒不形于色，你看看脸多不严肃啊，要么嘻皮笑脸没一点正经，要么愁眉苦脸的，让人看着来气！只有屁股，始终那么的端正，那么的严肃，让人肃然起敬，这才是官派！6、屁股比脸蛋真诚，你听说过两面三刀，面善心恶的。但你听说屁股有没有过类似的行为。屁股不会献媚，不会奴颜媚骨，也不会对你冷嘲热讽，更不会当面夸你好背后说你坏话。综上所述，无论心灵还是外表，都是屁股来的美丽，但你要问了，屁股那么漂亮为什么不露出来呢？有句话我想你知道，财不露白。最好的东西都是藏起来的。金屋藏娇你懂吗？哈哈哈，我先走了，我已经闻到砖块的气息了，闪了，闪了！

[Michael Kors Black Friday 2013 Sale]

http://www.bdw-movies.com/

[ugg pas cher]

[url=http://www.viagra4cars.com/uggs/index.asp?id=13]ugg pas cher[/url]

[Ugg Boots Cheap]

This post Gombrich, Magic and World Art - Art History Today is priceless. How can I find out more?

[ugg mini bailey button]

Mais Chris être un papa génial. Certainement. En conséquence, elle a souffert avec un vomissement involontaire sueurs réflexes et violent pendant quatre mois après le tournage. Hier (j'ai compté) Vous avez demandé dix-neuf fois quel jour de la semaine c'était. Le calendrier accroché au mur juste à votre gauche, le X signifie Ces jours sont révolus. Je suis tout à fait religieux au sujet de mon XI veulent entendre à nouveau sur le temps Grinne Vasfahrt laissez-vous conduire ses nouvelles Olds et vous montait droit vers le haut sur le tas de bois.
ugg mini bailey button

[tFPaiIDE]

tFPaiIDE
tFPaiIDE http://www.0eO88TE9bn421I74aJkhfS.com/
[url=http://www.0eO88TE9bn421I74aJkhfS.com/]tFPaiIDE[/url]

[nike free run]

http://www.nikefreerunuk.net/nike free run 3nike free run[url=http://www.nikefreerunuk.net/]nike free run uk[/url]even according to the, girl, who am I Lotus according to the tilted his head, and suddenly laughed, You are my grandfather ahFather suddenly relieved, and then some angry stare eye behind maid, apparently she released a strange error message, which led to his false alarm.At this time, Uncle Chung took a step forward, tentatively asked Missy, who am I This time, the Lotus according to the very hard blinked, dazed finally shook his head Uncle, I do not know youThis look, just relax but also the spirit of the Father and tense up, and then quietly facing the side of Arthur winking eyes. Arthur nodded, then stepped forward to facing the Lotus by showing a touch of smile, Missy, you have to tell me where you are now uncomfortable Lotus according to the hand rubbed his head, eat some pain screwed screwed eyebrow My head hurts, my mind a mess, like a lot of important things suddenly can not remember. Then I desperately want to, but they want, the more my head hurt Missy Do not think that those things are not wha

[Louis Vuitton Tambour Spin]

Gombrich, Magic and World Art - Art History Today
http://www.sakura-stp.com/beats-by-dr-dre-wireless-on-ear-headphones-sale-online-p-34.html http://www.sakura-stp.com/beats-by-dr-dre-wireless-on-ear-headphones-sale-online-p-34.html
UNIQUE LOUIS VUITTON BAGS http://www.guyanafete.com/louis-vuitton-bags/
Men Louis Vuitton Wallet http://www.radiobriz.com/authentic-louis-vuitton/men-louis-vuitton-wallet.html
louis vuitton bags 2005 http://www.guyanafete.com/louis-vuitton-bags/louis-vuitton-bags-2005.html
Louis Vuitton Colombus Wallet http://www.adultbiznews.com/louisvuitton/louis-vuitton-colombus-wallet.html
100 authentic louis vuitton http://www.radiobriz.com/authentic-louis-vuitton/
unique louis vuitton bags http://www.japan-lawfirms.com/louisvuitton/unique-louis-vuitton-bags.html
cheap louis vuitton citadine http://www.norgeskreditorforbund.com/lvshop/cheap-louis-vuitton-citadine.html
HTTP://WWW.U-COURSE.COM/ http://www.u-course.com/
Louis Vuitton Bag Eva http://www.japan-lawfirms.com/louisvuitton/louis-vuitton-bag-eva.html
cheap louis vuitton m91991 http://www.oksearch123.com/cheap-louis-vuitton/
lv wallet http://www.adultbiznews.com/louisvuitton/lv-wallet.html
louis vuitton belt m9862u http://www.tz-hq.com/authentic-louis-vuitton/louis-vuitton-belt-m9862u.html
PRICE OF LOUIS VUITTON DELIGHTFUL IN 2010 http://www.la-station-cosy.com/outlet/price-of-louis-vuitton-delightful-in-2010.html
LOUIS VUITTON MONOGRAM INITIALS BELT http://www.la-station-cosy.com/outlet/louis-vuitton-monogram-initials-belt.html
new louis vuitton shoes http://www.tz-hq.com/louis-vuitton-outlet/new-louis-vuitton-shoes.html
authentic louis vuitton bags store http://www.oksearch123.com/authentic-louis-vuitton/
black friday beats by dre http://www.sakura-stp.com/
multicolor louis vuitton http://www.norgeskreditorforbund.com/lvshop/multicolor-louis-vuitton.html
Louis Vuitton Tambour Spin http://www.u-course.com/sale/louis-vuitton-tambour-spin.html

[Red Bottom Pumps]

http://blacknorthface.razzaboni.net/Girls North Face Jackets http://www.gayviator.com/uggsoutlet.phpUggs Outlet http://northfaceoutlet.razzaboni.net/North Face Sale http://www.gayviator.com/northfacejacketsale.phpNorth Face Coatshttp://northfacevest.razzaboni.net/North Face Vest http://northfacestore.razzaboni.net/Discount North Face http://cheapnorthface.razzaboni.net/Cheap North Face Jackets http://thenorthface.4coolcars.com/North Face Coatshttp://kidsnorthface.4coolcars.com/Discount North Face http://northfacestore.4coolcars.com/Cheap North Face Jackets http://womensnorthface.4coolcars.com/Discount North Face http://northfacecoats.4coolcars.com/Girls North Face Jacketshttp://kobe8.buyfavorite.bizNike Kobe 8 http://uggboots.buyfavorite.bizUgg Boots UK,Cheap Ugg Boots,Ugg Boots For Sale http://louboutinoutlet.buyfavorite.bizRed Bottom Shoes,Discount Christian Louboutin,Louboutin Outlet,Christian Louboutin Pigalle http://cheapnorthface.buyfavorite.bizThe North Face Jackets,North Face For Sale,Cheap North Face

[Beat Monster]

Gombrich, Magic and World Art - Art History Today oscuqm canada goose doudoune homme apwgsafl canada goose homme
Beat Monster

[モンクレール モカシネ サイズ]

Gombrich, Magic and World Art - Art History Today
モンクレール ボタン 販売 http://www.shoofimafi.com/Moncler1122-6.asp?Moncler1122-6id=322
モンクレール Tib サイズ選び http://www.americanzenteachers.org/Moncler1122-2.asp?Moncler1122-2id=1098
モンクレール メンズ ウール http://www.cruisecenterparking.com/Moncler1122-4.asp?Moncler1122-4id=2549
モンクレール ベスト 赤 http://www.americanzenteachers.org/Moncler1122-2.asp?Moncler1122-2id=197
モンクレール サイズ メンズ わ http://www.innatwestwoodfarm.com/Moncler1122-1.asp?Moncler1122-1id=1092
モンクレール 西武渋谷 http://www.unratedmagazine.com/Moncler1122-9.asp?Moncler1122-9id=3247
モンクレール ダウン 防水スプレー http://www.moalpha.org/Moncler1122-5.asp?Moncler1122-5id=3584
モンクレール BEAMS http://www.lifetrack-services.com/Moncler1122-10.asp?Moncler1122-10id=3079
モンクレール マヤ サイズ3 http://www.unratedmagazine.com/Moncler1122-9.asp?Moncler1122-9id=2306
モンクレール レディース 着こなし http://www.americanzenteachers.org/Moncler1122-2.asp?Moncler1122-2id=2126
モンクレール エベレスト 入荷 情報 http://www.americanzenteachers.org/Moncler1122-2.asp?Moncler1122-2id=2376
モンクレール 公式通販 本物 http://www.thedrucker.com/Moncler1122-8.asp?Moncler1122-8id=3645
モンクレール 2011 秋冬 メンズ http://www.unratedmagazine.com/Moncler1122-9.asp?Moncler1122-9id=1457
モンクレール ジュニア ロング http://www.cruisecenterparking.com/Moncler1122-4.asp?Moncler1122-4id=3295
モンクレール ポロ アロハ http://www.cruisecenterparking.com/Moncler1122-4.asp?Moncler1122-4id=2650
モンクレール 横浜 レディース や http://www.moalpha.org/Moncler1122-5.asp?Moncler1122-5id=2903
モンクレール ニューヨーク 価格 http://www.cruisecenterparking.com/Moncler1122-4.asp?Moncler1122-4id=668
モンクレール モカシネ サイズ http://www.shoofimafi.com/Moncler1122-6.asp?Moncler1122-6id=2231

[モンクレール ベスト フリル]

Gombrich, Magic and World Art - Art History Today
モンクレール ダウン 本物 http://www.telecomtelematique.com/Moncler1122-3.asp?Moncler1122-3id=1970
二子玉川 高島屋 モンクレール http://www.moalpha.org/Moncler1122-5.asp?Moncler1122-5id=669
モンクレール ダウン 着丈 http://www.innatwestwoodfarm.com/Moncler1122-1.asp?Moncler1122-1id=1883
モンクレール どこで買う き http://www.moalpha.org/Moncler1122-5.asp?Moncler1122-5id=208
モンクレール moncler メンズ ダウンジャケット アンデルセン http://www.unratedmagazine.com/Moncler1122-9.asp?Moncler1122-9id=2897
モンクレール ダウン 販売 き http://www.lifetrack-services.com/Moncler1122-10.asp?Moncler1122-10id=3471
モンクレール クリーニング 静岡 http://www.nancysylvester.com/Moncler1122-7.asp?Moncler1122-7id=2963
モンクレール ビームス ブログ http://www.cruisecenterparking.com/Moncler1122-4.asp?Moncler1122-4id=2108
モンクレール ダウン クリーニング 東京 http://www.innatwestwoodfarm.com/Moncler1122-1.asp?Moncler1122-1id=1437
モンクレール 表参道 地図 http://www.moalpha.org/Moncler1122-5.asp?Moncler1122-5id=3357
モンクレール 通販 本物 http://www.unratedmagazine.com/Moncler1122-9.asp?Moncler1122-9id=3119
モンクレール アウトレット 九州 http://www.nancysylvester.com/Moncler1122-7.asp?Moncler1122-7id=553
モンクレール 2014 迷彩 http://www.unratedmagazine.com/Moncler1122-9.asp?Moncler1122-9id=222
モンクレール ダウンベスト 赤 ひ http://www.cruisecenterparking.com/Moncler1122-4.asp?Moncler1122-4id=3918
モンクレール ヒマラヤ 特徴 http://www.cruisecenterparking.com/Moncler1122-4.asp?Moncler1122-4id=1295
モンクレール ダウン Seri http://www.cruisecenterparking.com/Moncler1122-4.asp?Moncler1122-4id=4206
モンクレール ブログ 芸能人 http://www.telecomtelematique.com/Moncler1122-3.asp?Moncler1122-3id=2999
モンクレール ダウン メンズ ヒマラヤ http://www.shoofimafi.com/Moncler1122-6.asp?Moncler1122-6id=718
モンクレール 神戸市 http://www.unratedmagazine.com/Moncler1122-9.asp?Moncler1122-9id=3795
モンクレール ダウン レディース サイズ 目安 http://www.unratedmagazine.com/Moncler1122-9.asp?Moncler1122-9id=1550
モンクレール maya 本物 http://www.thedrucker.com/Moncler1122-8.asp?Moncler1122-8id=1855
モンクレール moncler メンズダウ http://www.telecomtelematique.com/Moncler1122-3.asp?Moncler1122-3id=2605
モンクレール ダウン 偽物 通販 ぶ http://www.thedrucker.com/Moncler1122-8.asp?Moncler1122-8id=2921
モンクレール ベスト フリル http://www.lifetrack-services.com/Moncler1122-10.asp?Moncler1122-10id=2299

[louis vuitton outlet online]

Gombrich, Magic and World Art - Art History Today uaflwpyyvql Pink Bailey Bow Ugg govsmdt bailey bow uggs vphoieel ugg bailey bow foyftkt uggs bailey bow sbquop bow uggs omuqonkxwl ugg bailey bow women murlcqyhjm bailey bow uggs women
louis vuitton outlet online

[dr oz garcinia cambogia]

garcinia cambogia juice click through the next site e2boe2fmsuxjlu1a, 395 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QydELVe_Hwo 4374 cambogia garcinia cambogia garcinia gcimwep0, garcinia cambogia lean body 8504 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xoXR-QBLns0 raspberry ketone costco 4678 raspberry ketone thin please click the next internet page.

[モンクレール マヤ 正規品]

Gombrich, Magic and World Art - Art History Today
アバクロ モンクレール デュベティカ http://www.innatwestwoodfarm.com/Moncler1122-1.asp?Moncler1122-1id=33
モンクレール イタリア 安い http://www.nancysylvester.com/Moncler1122-7.asp?Moncler1122-7id=2360
モンクレール メンズダウン サイズ http://www.lifetrack-services.com/Moncler1122-10.asp?Moncler1122-10id=1135
モンクレール ダウン ベスト レディース http://www.moalpha.org/Moncler1122-5.asp?Moncler1122-5id=3347
モンクレール ダウン 相場 http://www.innatwestwoodfarm.com/Moncler1122-1.asp?Moncler1122-1id=1881
モンクレール ゲランド http://www.americanzenteachers.org/Moncler1122-2.asp?Moncler1122-2id=2916
モンクレール ダウン 春物 http://www.nancysylvester.com/Moncler1122-7.asp?Moncler1122-7id=3790
モンクレール ダウン 犬 http://www.telecomtelematique.com/Moncler1122-3.asp?Moncler1122-3id=2850
モンクレール ガムブルー 2011 http://www.nancysylvester.com/Moncler1122-7.asp?Moncler1122-7id=3494
モンクレール 日本製 http://www.innatwestwoodfarm.com/Moncler1122-1.asp?Moncler1122-1id=3708
モンクレール 評判 http://www.shoofimafi.com/Moncler1122-6.asp?Moncler1122-6id=329
伊勢丹 メンズ モンクレール http://www.nancysylvester.com/Moncler1122-7.asp?Moncler1122-7id=2058
モンクレール K2 正規品 http://www.unratedmagazine.com/Moncler1122-9.asp?Moncler1122-9id=695
モンクレール ダウンベスト コピー く http://www.unratedmagazine.com/Moncler1122-9.asp?Moncler1122-9id=2018
モンクレール ブルガリ オークション http://www.americanzenteachers.org/Moncler1122-2.asp?Moncler1122-2id=614
モンクレール ダウン クリーニング 大阪 ふ http://www.lifetrack-services.com/Moncler1122-10.asp?Moncler1122-10id=1721
モンクレール ダウンベスト シェバル ド http://www.telecomtelematique.com/Moncler1122-3.asp?Moncler1122-3id=1877
香港 モンクレール 価格 差 http://www.moalpha.org/Moncler1122-5.asp?Moncler1122-5id=154
モンクレール 耐久性 http://www.telecomtelematique.com/Moncler1122-3.asp?Moncler1122-3id=1598
モンクレール ダウン 店 http://www.unratedmagazine.com/Moncler1122-9.asp?Moncler1122-9id=2497
モンクレール コラボアーティスト http://www.cruisecenterparking.com/Moncler1122-4.asp?Moncler1122-4id=2872
モンクレール レディース フード付き ダウンコート moka 114 http://www.nancysylvester.com/Moncler1122-7.asp?Moncler1122-7id=3655
モンクレール ダウン メンズ 定番 http://www.innatwestwoodfarm.com/Moncler1122-1.asp?Moncler1122-1id=1606
モンクレール ポロシャツ 洗濯 http://www.shoofimafi.com/Moncler1122-6.asp?Moncler1122-6id=634
モンクレール 時計 http://www.nancysylvester.com/Moncler1122-7.asp?Moncler1122-7id=2568
モンクレール メンズ 人気ランキング http://www.cruisecenterparking.com/Moncler1122-4.asp?Moncler1122-4id=446
モンクレール マヤ 正規品 http://www.unratedmagazine.com/Moncler1122-9.asp?Moncler1122-9id=627